On one hand, the passing of such a law would make every image copying illegal, every small digital footstep would have to be taken with caution. But thats mainly because of the wording of the law.
What about the principles?
A lot of people find that paying for music or movies or games or software is too expensive. So they decide to 'share'. Most of the people against piracy laws feel that artists and copyright owners already make so much money by selling original stuffs to so many people, so what difference does a few dollars make?
What people don't realize is that if governments allow these acts to continue without trying to stop them, then slowly everyone will decide to become a pirate, and nobody would buy original things. This would hurt copywriters as well, as there would be little revenue/incentive for producing new work and thus creativity would reduce. Its like parking tickets. Governments and local city councils keep these laws to ensure order in society. Otherwise we would all become savage beasts.
However, this does not mean that I am 100% for anti-piracy laws. Some things must be pirated from online because the original discs are too expensive or are not even available. Some of them are not available at all, while some are not available in certain geographic locations. Some software, for example, is downloaded thru file sharing because they have been unheard of and so people want to try them out.
What would be a better solution to curb piracy? In my opinion I think that after few years (5 or so years) the movie, software or whatever should be made available online. This is so that people can still legally download them in case they are not available (like some old movies). Also, there should be pay per download file sharing everywhere in the world. Currently these are available in the west, and even in the east but not in all countries. This encourages piracy. And these payments should be made cheap because by using the web, the producers/owners cost of distribution and selling has gone lower, and these savings should be passed on :)
I think that this compromise would be in the best interest for everyone. The anti-pirates and the freedom of speech and democracy supporters :)
Cheers
Mazaher